
- aye carumba
Before we get to the (DELICIOUS!!!!!!) forbidden cookies, let’s do a quick recap of the day
I started things off with a 30-minute walk in the park with Arthur, then came home to plain Whole Soy yogurt with 1/2 c. Udi’s Vanilla Granola (I didn’t add fruit because I didn’t want any; I think I may have overdone it yesterday!):

For lunch I packed another plain Whole Soy yogurt with a mix of 1/4 c. peanuts and 1/4 c. Udi’s vanilla granola (redundant, I know, but it’s just SO good!), plus some baby carrots, and a wrap with spinach, 1/4 an avocado, a tiny bit of Sabra’s spicy hummus, and a little cubed tofu (I should have taken a picture of the inside of the wrap; it was quite colorful and SO good!):

I had the yogurt + toppings at 11, then took a 20-minute walk on my lunch break, and had the wrap and carrots around 1:15.
I got home around 5:45 and gobbled down a quick dinner before a walk date with my friend:
~1.5 c. whole-wheat pasta with tomato/veggie “meat” sauce (leftover from a big batch that Sonny and I made on Sunday night—it’s one of our standby meals)
random (and delicious) sides: 1/4 an avocado and black olives
and a dried pineapple ring, on the way out the door, just ’cause I needed something sweet
This dinner was PERFECT fuel for my walk—energizing but not too heavy. There was a time when pasta was a forbidden food for me, but I’m glad that time is over—every once in awhile it just hits the spot! We walked/ran around in the park with Arthur for a little over an hour and it was perfection.
When I came home I was craving fresh fruits & veggies but also needed something with staying power (and didn’t want to be starving when I made the cookies!) so I had carrots, strawberries, and a tablespoon of cashew butter:

SO HAPPY to be enjoying strawberries again!!! All in all, a great day of food and activity
* * *
Onto the cookies.
I googled “the best vegan chocolate chip cookies ever” and found this recipe. After reading all the rave reviews in the comments, I knew this was it! I followed the recipe with the following substitutions: used half all-purpose flour and half white whole-wheat flour (the VERY last of both—I had just enough flour in the house to make these! a sign perhaps?), and added 1 tbsp. blackstrap molasses (just because I love the depth of flavor that it gives to baked goods!)
Oh, and rather than chocolate chips, I went super-gourmet and used a bar of Lindt superdark chocolate, broken into chunks

(That’s the piece that never made it into the batter—and it DEFINITELY would have been more if I hadn’t been taking pictures for the blog!
)
Mixing the dry ingredients was no problem, but the “forbidden food stress” set in when I got here:
1 c. demerara sugar mixed with 1/2 c. canola oil
I never, NEVER!! bake anything with this much sugar and oil in it. Ever. But I’m never quite satisfied with my baked goods, either
. And let me tell you, this cookie batter was incredible:
Yup, that’s my portion
And I’m so glad I tried it!!!
The instructions say to remove cookies while they’re still soft and let them harden out of the oven. This yielded a cookie that was crisp on the outside, with a chewy, soft center. A.K.A. heaven:


I baked the first batch for the recommended time (5 minutes + 4 minutes + 2 minutes), but took the second batch out after only 5 minutes to see how they turned out. Of course, I tasted one of each batch:
Batch 1, front
Batch 1, back (LOOK AT THAT CHOCOLATE!!!)
Batch 2
Let me tell you, batch 2 was INCREDIBLE!! It retained all the gooeyness of the cookie dough but still had a delicate, crispy exterior. I savored every single crumb.
* * *
Reflections: I enjoyed every moment of making these cookies, and have faith that I’ll be able to enjoy them one (or two
) at a time for the rest of the week. Having the blog/challenge to report to (and taking pictures!) really helped keep my dough-snacking in check, too (I used to make cookies purely as an excuse to eat dough!!). The finished product was SO delicious that I don’t want to eat them all at once—I want to enjoy them all week!
I have a lot more thoughts on this, but I’ll reflect on them as the week goes on. Among them: I really must have obsessed about these cookies for awhile, because I googled “the best vegan chocolate chip cookies ever” a month or so ago (and kept the recipe in my e-mail inbox, but never made it!). Also, it’s not the cookies themselves that are “dangerous” to me, it’s the fact that I avoided making/eating them for so long! And finally, it was very empowering for me to make the cookies, enjoy them, and reach a point of satisfaction (right now, I truly don’t want another one!). I only hope this feeling carries through the rest of the week.
* * *
Finally (for real this time) I am SO impressed with the responses I’ve gotten to the challenge. Coconut-milk ice cream, lemon curd, pecans, peanut butter, cadbury mini eggs, twizzlers, reese’s peanut butter cups . . . from frugal shoppers to former dieters to recovering anorexics, you guys have already incorporated new and formerly black-listed foods in a healthy way and taken a step toward asserting control over them. Every one of you inspires me so much!!!
And remember: all of you—bloggers and non-bloggers alike—are welcome to enter the challenge between now and Sunday! Either share your experience with your forbidden food on your blog and link to this post [challenge details can be found here], or leave a comment on the same post sharing your experience. At the end of the week, I’ll recap everyone’s stories, and a random participant will receive a special surprise package
March 18, 2009 at 11:15 am
Hey girl, those cookies look AWESOME! What a great challenge you’re on and you’re doing so well! I think this is a great experiment – you have somewhere to “report” to, but there’s no extreme pressure. I’m sure you’ll be able to enjoy these cookies much more than if you didn’t have this blog & the challenge.
March 18, 2009 at 12:43 pm
great job Vani – those cookies look amazing, and the best part is that they’re still healthy!
I can’t wait to see everyone else’s challenge entries
March 18, 2009 at 1:48 pm
OMG, those cookies look incredible!! i do the SAME thing when it comes to oil and sugar in baked goods and always try to substitute/healthify (of course, i’ve got no trouble eating cookies someone else makes/brings, but i can’t make or buy real ones myself). the substitutions usually work well, except with cookies! i think they just need the oil/sugar to get the right crunch. you’ve inspired me to make “the real thing” next time i get the urge
March 18, 2009 at 2:09 pm
wow you did so good! love that you are doing this challenge, so inspirational! they look absolutely amazing.. i have that same problem with cookie dough too! ill eat the dough until theres not much left to make the actual cookies lol
March 18, 2009 at 2:12 pm
I love your forbidden food challenge and those cookies really do look incredible!
March 18, 2009 at 2:28 pm
Oh my gosh – those vegan cookies look INCREDIBLE!! Well done
You’re doing so well with this challenge!!
March 18, 2009 at 2:30 pm
Good job so far on the challenge, 1 or 2 cookies can definitely become part of ‘the bigger picture’ that is a healthy lifestyle! And let me just say, those cookies just look so darn good!!!
March 18, 2009 at 5:15 pm
Vani, those cookies look AMAZING!! I am so proud of you for making them and being able to enjoy the experience. Cookies are also another one of my “forbidden foods”…I also used to make them just to eat the dough! I haven’t made them in so long because I just don’t trust myself, but you are inspiring me
We’ll see how this challenge goes, and then I’ll have to think about baking cookies again sometime. You’re right, it certainly does help to have a blog to have to report back to. If it wasn’t for that, I may have been done for last night! Great job!!
March 18, 2009 at 8:39 pm
Yay! Great job with the cookies! They look awesome
Thanks so much for making this challenge. It’s really inspiring!
March 18, 2009 at 8:42 pm
i actually contemplated making
those cookies when i was home
last weekend. now i wish i would
have. but i have all next week
to make them during spring break!
March 19, 2009 at 1:19 am
[...] (can’t get enough!), fresh ripe strawberries, the other half of this morning’s mango, a forbidden cookie!, baby carrots, and a container of frozen mixed veggies (carrots, peas, beans, okra, potatoes) with [...]
March 19, 2009 at 1:45 pm
Your blog provides a fresh look at the subject. You might want to take a look at my blog and possibly become a regular reader.
Free Samples. Updated with a complete new list of Free Stuff every 24 hours.
http://lm.logicalmedia.com/z/8578/CD2855
March 20, 2009 at 2:25 pm
[...] me give you an update on my forbidden food: the forbidden cookies. I never thought I could keep something like this in the house without losing control and eating [...]
March 21, 2009 at 3:34 am
[...] for work: melon from breakfast, a forbidden cookie, another plain Whole Soy yogurt (my last! ), baby carrots, and an Ezekiel wrap with 1/4 an [...]
March 23, 2009 at 1:50 pm
[...] for my recap. My forbidden food was homemade REAL chocolate-chip cookies, but a few others came up for me along the way (processed carbs being the major culprit!) I did [...]
March 26, 2009 at 2:40 pm
[...] wrap with 1 tbsp. cashew butter and a forbidden cookie (eaten [...]
April 3, 2009 at 6:05 pm
[...] efforts! Meghann and her coworkers reviewed the cookies in this post, and I enjoyed them in this one I promsie you they’ll look prettier than they did in the package I sent to Meghann—I got a [...]
April 4, 2009 at 11:22 pm
wow they look great!